Court of Appeals of Texas June 15, 1978, No. 8148 (National Maritime Union v. Altman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1978

KEITH, Justice.

Defendant below appeals from an order entered in the trial court enforcing an agreement to settle a disputed claim theretofore pending in such court. We affirm.

Plaintiff below, the widow of a member of the defendant union, claimed that she was entitled to benefits from the pension plan provided by the union. She brought suit claiming benefits of approximately $18,000 and the defendant answered by a general denial. After some discovery, and at a time when the case was upon a trial setting, counsel for the parties entered into settlement negotiations which finally culminated in plaintiff’s counsel addressing a letter to defendant’s counsel offering to settle the case for the cash payment of $12,000. A month later, defendant’s counsel sent him a form of judgment to be entered which correctly set out the terms of the compromise, and a set of releases to be executed by plaintiff and her counsel.

The covering letter transmitting the settlement documents included in its caption the cause number and style of the pending litigation, and we set out its contents in the margin.1 Plaintiff, who resided in the State of Mississippi, came to Texas, signed the documents as requested by defendant’s counsel, and her lawyer then returned them to defendant’s counsel.

Thereafter, the New York office — at the time the check was being “cut” — discovered (so it claims in an affidavit of one of its agents) that plaintiff, having earlier drawn certain financial benefits from the union fund, was not entitled to $12,000 but a smaller sum. It then instructed its counsel of record to repudiate the settlement agreement.

Upon notice of repudiation of the agreement, plaintiff then filed her motion in the original and still pending suit to enforce such settlement agreement. After a hearing and the receipt of testimony, the trial court entered the judgment originally submitted by defendant’s counsel to the plaintiff which had been repudiated by his client.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.