Kentucky Supreme Court July 3, 1978 (Stephens v. Kentucky Utilities Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1978

STEPHENSON, Justice.

The question presented on this appeal is whether the order of the Franklin Circuit Court remanding the case to the Public Service Commission is an appealable order. The Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal of the movants on the ground that the order of remand was not a final appealable order. We grant discretionary review and reverse.

On July 10,1974, the Public Service Commission entered an order fixing new electric rates for Kentucky Utilities. In May 1974, Kentucky Utilities had put new rates into effect subject to refund. The July 10,1974, order prescribed lower rates and directed refund of the difference.

On September 6,1974, Kentucky Utilities, the Attorney General, and Lexington-Fa-yette Urban County Government as inter-venors sought judicial review of the order of the Public Service Commission in Franklin Circuit Court, and the cases were subsequently consolidated.

On December 6, 1974, Kentucky Utilities sought and was, in March 1975, granted a temporary injunction allowing collection of the higher rates pending final disposition of the appeals.

After this there was apparently a protracted period of legal skirmishing culminating in the amended and substituted order of March 25, 1977, entered by the trial court, which in part reads:

“On the Court’s own motion, and after hearing and argument, it appearing that the Court’s orders of February 17, 1977 and March 16, 1977, should be amended and restated by this substituted order, as follows:

“Kentucky Utilities Company has moved to remand these consolidated actions to the Public Service Commission to take new evidence, and after consideration thereof, entered a proper order thereon.

“These consolidated actions have been brought to review the Commission’s July 10, 1974 order which prescribed rates for the Company’s Kentucky Jurisdiction customers. The rates are lower than those the Company had put into effect on notice to the Commission May 15, 1974.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.