Tennessee Supreme Court October 2, 1978 (City of Lenoir City v. State ex rel. City of Loudon)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-10-1978

OPINION

BROCK, Justice.

This is a mandamus action by the City of Loudon to require the City of Lenoir City and Lenoir City Utilities Board to submit to arbitration as required by T.C.A., § 6-318,1 for the purpose of reaching an agreement for the transfer of utility functions and facilities to Loudon.

In 1977, the City of Loudon, by Ordinance No. 569, annexed a territory that is presently provided with electricity by Lenoir City Utilities. The annexed area includes the Union Carbide Corporation, an industrial park of approximately 280 acres and a road leading to the industrial park. After annexation, Loudon, pursuant to T.C.A., § 6-318, notified Lenoir City and its Utilities Board that it desired to purchase all utility functions and facilities in the area. Lenoir City rejected the offer to negotiate the transfer, contending that municipalities are not “affected instrumentalities” under T.C.A., § 6-318, and, therefore, that it does not have to comply with the provisions of that statute.

The City of Loudon filed a petition for mandamus in the Circuit Court of Loudon County to require Lenoir City to submit the issues to arbitration as required by the statute. The case was submitted to the trial court on a stipulation of fact. The trial court found that the City of Loudon had the exclusive right to provide utility services in the newly annexed territory. An alternative writ of mandamus was issued but a discretionary appeal under T.C.A., § 27-305, was granted on the following question, certified by the trial court: Whether a municipality is “any affected instrumentality of the state” within the meaning of T.C.A., § 6-318.

In support of its contention that a municipality is not an affected instrumentality of the state, Lenoir City relies on the case of Hamilton County v. City of Chattanooga, 203 Tenn. 85, 310 S.W.2d 153 (1958), wherein it is stated concerning T.C.A., § 6-318:

*299. .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.