Tennessee Supreme Court November 6, 1978 (State v. Pigford)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-1978

OPINION

HENRY, Chief Justice.

The State has brought this petition for the common law writs of certiorari and supersedeas to review the action of the trial court in granting the respondent’s motion to suppress evidence on the grounds that the search warrant used to seize the drugs involved in this case was illegal because it allegedly was not issued to a proper peace officer under § 40-505, T.C.A.

The stipulated facts disclose that on February 4, 1976, B. Griggs, “a duly commissioned law enforcement officer of the Federal Government” employed by the Federal Drug Enforcement Agency, appeared before a Shelby County General Sessions Judge and executed an “affidavit for search warrant” for the residence of respondent, Dale Pigford. The warrant thus procured was addressed “To the Sheriff, Any Constable or Any Peace Officer of [Shelby] County,” and commanded the search of respondent’s premises and property. Griggs was accompanied by J. L. Hamby, a Shelby County Deputy Sheriff. Later the same day, Hamby and two other deputy sheriffs accompanied by Griggs, executed the warrant and discovered marijuana at respondent’s residence. Deputy Hamby executed the return on the search warrant.

Respondent filed a motion to suppress, in which he contended that a search warrant, otherwise regular, is rendered invalid under § 40-505, T.C.A., by its issuance to a federal officer.1 The trial judge sustained this con*922tention, held the warrant invalid, and ruled that any evidence seized pursuant to it was inadmissible.

The action of the trial court has effectively ended the prosecution of this case and leaves the State with no other plain, speedy or adequate remedy. This is tantamount to the denial to the State of its day in court and results in the loss of an interest not subject to recapture. In such a case the State may properly seek review of the trial court’s action by means of the common law writ of certiorari. See State v. Johnson, 569 S.W.2d 808 (Tenn.1978); State v. Gant, 537 S.W.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.