Court of Appeals of Texas December 14, 1978, No. 8143 (Holt v. Community Development & Construction Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1978
CLAYTON, Justice.
Plaintiff and defendant entered into a written contract under which plaintiff was hired as subcontractor to install a foundation for the Sales and Information Center located at The Woodlands, Texas. Plaintiff brought this action against defendant, the *396general contractor, to recover the balance due for “retainage” under the written contract and for extra work performed on behalf of defendant. Defendant answered by claiming off-sets against the plaintiff in an amount in excess of plaintiff’s claim. The trial was to the court, and a take nothing judgment was entered against plaintiff, from which judgment plaintiff appeals.
The trial court filed findings of fact and conclusions of law to the effect that (1) the amount of $7,416.05 as retainage under the contract was due and owing to plaintiff, (2) plaintiff was entitled to $2,217.69 for extra work performed, (3) defendant was required to expend $13,668.02 to correct defects in workmanship in work performed by plaintiff, and (4) the sum expended by defendant to correct defects in workmanship exceeds the amount for the retainage and extra work performed by plaintiff, and therefore (5) plaintiff shall take nothing against defendant.
Plaintiff-appellant complains of the admission into evidence of certain exhibits which defendant introduced proving up the off-set relied upon by defendant. All three exhibits were summaries of the records kept by defendant. The defendant relied solely upon these summaries to prove up the amount it contended was due defendant because of the curative work performed as a result of the defect in workmanship of the work performed by plaintiff. The summaries were prepared from the records, but none of the individual records were introduced.
There are well-established principles applicable to summaries of voluminous records. Since a summary is no more admissible than the underlying records, the admissibility of the underlying records must be established.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit