Court of Appeals of Kentucky December 19, 1978 (Barnes v. Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1978

STERNBERG, Justice.

The movant (Barnes) seeks to recover damages from the respondent (The Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company (C&O)) for personal injuries received by him while employed by the Holland Company (Holland), allegedly the agent of C&O. The primary question is: By whom was Barnes employed at the time of his injuries?

Barnes charges that the C&O is using Holland as a subterfuge to avoid the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA). He further states that in truth and in fact Holland is the agent of C&O and he, in turn, as an employee of Holland at the time of his injuries was actually an employee of C&O under the terms of FELA and entitled to its benefits. This is denied by C&O.

On October 16, 1970, the C&O entered into a “lease and agreement” with Holland whereby Holland would operate C&O’s rail-welding plant. By the terms of the “lease and agreement,” Holland undertook the task of joining sections of rails to a designated length by the use of specialty-type welding equipment owned by Holland. On July 15, 1971, and again on April 2, 1973, Barnes was injured while assisting a fellow employee in doing the work they were employed by Holland to do.

On October 29, 1973, Barnes filed suit against the C&O in the Greenup Circuit Court seeking to recover damages in the sum of $300,000 for personal injuries. Depositions, interrogatories and their answers, and affidavits were filed in support of motions for summary judgment by both Barnes and C&O. In Kelley v. Southern Pacific Company, 419 U.S. 318, 95 S.Ct. 472, 42 L.Ed.2d 498 (1974), the court said: “Under the FELA, a covered railroád is liable for negligently causing the injury or death of any person ‘while he is employed’ by the railroad. Although petitioner acknowledged that he was technically in the employ of a trucking company rather than the railroad, he contended that his work was sufficiently under the control of the railroad to bring him within the coverage of FELA.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.