Supreme Court of Oklahoma October 3, 1978, No. 51344 (Sears, Roebuck & Co. v. Armstrong)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-1978

WILLIAMS, J.

A claim for compensation alleged disability from accidental injury sustained during course of employment as a shipping clerk in the retail store operated by petitioner, hereafter respondent.

Respondent denied all allegations of the claim except fact of employment. Respondent specifically denied claimant was engaged in hazardous employment defined by law, or that the retail sales store was hazardous employment enumerated by statute, 85 O.S.1971 §§ 2, 3.

Claimant was employed as a receiving clerk at respondent’s Midwest City, Oklahoma store. His principal duty was to unload *350trucks which delivered merchandise to the back of the store. Some of this merchandise would be placed in a storage area of the main store by use of hand dollies. Large items, such as refrigerators, were placed in a warehouse several yards from the loading dock. Claimant assisted in taking merchandise to the stockroom or from that point onto the sales floor, taking mail to the post office, and occasionally driving a delivery pickup to customers’ homes, or between stores transferring merchandise.

On November 29, 1975 claimant left the store to take mail to the post office. When stepping off the dock into the truck his foot slipped and he fell and injured the left knee. Respondent paid claimant’s medical bills, and also paid wages in lieu of compensation.

Claimant testified respondent had two gas-powered forklift trucks in the warehouse, which he had used once or twice a week. Respondent’s receiving manager testified there was no forklift truck in use, and merchandise was moved entirely by means of two-wheel dollies, or flatbed, four-wheeled dollies. During employment claimant never worked in any other department.

A trial judge found claimant sustained accidental personal injury arising out of and in course of employment, and awarded compensation for permanent partial disability (15%) to left knee. This order was affirmed by State Industrial Court en banc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.