Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York April 13, 1978, Claim No. 58287 (Cummings v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-04-1978

Appeal from a judgment in favor of claimant, entered September 21, 1976, upon a decision of the Court of Claims. On January 3, 1974, the State appropriated a permanent easement for a stream channel along the entire easterly portion of claimant’s property, located on Main Street in the Village of Unadilla, New York. The easement takes 43 feet along Main Street on the eastern side of claimant’s frontage and extends some 290 feet along claimant’s property, encompassing some .162 acre. The claimant’s two-story frame dwelling and detached garage were not located in the area appropriated. Claimant’s lot had 72 feet frontage on Main Street, and extended northward some 430 feet, was generally level at road grade, and was improved with a macadam surfaced driveway; a well supplementing village water, a septic system, and other land improvements, including a pergola. The lot was landscaped with lawn, foundation shrubs, large evergreen trees, deciduous trees, and a 98-foot hedge. The highest and best use of the property, prior to the appropriation was for a residence. The appraisers for the claimant and the State adopted the market value approach eliminating the income approach and cost approach as inappropriate for the subject property. Claimant’s appraiser fixed damages at $15,750, finding a before value of $26,100 and an after value of $13,500. The sum of $3,150 was then added as a "cost of cure” for replacement of the water well, cellar drain line and portions of the septic system. The claimant’s appraiser noted that the appropriation comes within two feet of the residence, which, he testified, makes the property less valuable on the open market. He placed a value of $7,000 on the land prior to appropriation. He determined the land had direct damages of $1,059 and consequential damages of $2,971. The comparable sales did not include any vacant land sales, and the appraiser had to abstract a land value from improved property sales.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.