New York Supreme Court December 5, 1978 (Lindsley v. Financial Collection Agencies, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1978

OPINION OF THE COURT

Joseph P. Kuszynski, J.

A trial before a jury was held in Cattaraugus County on September 27 and 28, 1978. At the end of plaintiffs case for *264conversion and trespass, it became clear that no question of fact was in issue — but one of law, specifically whether plaintiff as purchaser of an automobile from a dealer is entitled the protections afforded to consumers under subdivision (1) of section 9-307 of the Uniform Commercial Code.

The jury was then discharged and the parties stipulated on the amount of damages if the court found for the plaintiff. Submitted afterwards were memoranda on the law.

Plaintiff Robert A. Lindsley had purchased a used 1972 Ford Mustang automobile from H. R. Hunt Corporation, a dealer in new and used cars, located in East Aurora, New York, on October 23, 1976 and paid Hunt $2,031.65 for the vehicle.

On or about March 28, 1972 an earlier owner of the same vehicle, Virgil A. Aughtry, executed in favor of the defendant, Twenty-Nine Thirty-Nine Niagara Street Credit Union, a promissory note, a security agreement, and a standard form financing statement. This financing statement was filed in the Erie County clerk’s office on April 11, 1972 as provided in the Uniform Commercial Code. Aughtry then transferred the automobile to one Mary Cooper, who thereafter traded the automobile to plaintiff’s seller H. R. Hunt Corporation. This dealer and the credit union are located in Erie County.

Aughtry defaulted on his obligation with the defendant credit union some time prior to November 1, 1974 and the credit union referred the file to its attorney for collection purposes.

Plaintiff testified he had use of the automobile for five months when he received a phone call on March 30, 1977 from a Shirley Du Mont. She informed him, in substance, that she represented the defendant Financial Collection Agencies, Inc., which was acting on behalf of the credit union.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.