New York City Family Court June 16, 1978 (Schwartz v. Schwartz)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-06-1978
OPINION OF THE COURT
Arthur J. Abrams, J.
Respondent, by notice of motion dated April 11, 1978, moves for an order, pursuant to CPL 160.50, directing the return to him by the Division of Criminal Justice Services and involved law enforcement agencies, all photographs, fingerprints and other identification materials taken or made of respondent and the sealing of all official records and papers relating to respondent’s arrest and prosecution in this matter.
The provisions of CPL 160.50 are "triggered” by the termination of a criminal proceeding within the meaning of one of *1072the nine paragraphs ([a] through [j], inclusive) of subdivision 2 of the said section. The facts herein involved an alleged assault in the third degree (violation of Penal Law, § 120.00, subd 1) which petitioner commenced by misdemeanor information in the District Court of the County of Suffolk. The purported incident in question involved a husband and wife and occurred on August 26, 1977. Accordingly, the matter was transferred to the Family Court for hearing. After transfer to the Family Court and after several adjournments, the petition was dismissed for failure of prosecution.
Clearly, the case has been disposed of and had the matter been heard in a criminal court, it would have been dismissed pursuant to CPL 170.30. In that context, the provisions of CPL 160.50 would have come into play and the motion herein granted without question. We note, however, that the CPL is applicable to criminal proceedings only (see CPL 1.10). What then when confronted with a Family Court Act article 8 proceeding which is civil in nature? We know of no case in point, however, reasoning by analogy may prove to be of aid.
In Matter of Tony W. (91 Misc 2d 700, 701) the provisions of CPL 160.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit