Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania February 22, 1978, Appeal, No. 63 C.D. 1977 (Redevelopment Authority v. Wabank Real Estate & Investment Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-1978

lead-opinion

Opinion by

Judge Wilkinson, Jr.,

The Redevelopment Authority of the City of Lancaster (Authority) appeals an order of the Court of Common Pleas of Lancaster County dated December 17, 1976 remanding a report from the Board of Viewers (Board) in an eminent domain proceeding.

On June 3, 1974 the Authority filed a declaration of taking against four properties owned by Wabank Real Estate and Investment Company, Inc. and leased to the appellee herein, Miller & Son, Inc. At the time of condemnation appellee operated a barrel reconditioning business which it subsequently relocated to a new site in Lancaster, removing part of its equipment from the condemned properties to the new location. During a hearing before the Board appellee introduced evidence of moving costs, expenses to modify the new location and related costs. The Board, which found these costs to be “carefully documented,” determined that the sum of these costs would exceed $800,-000. The Authority introduced evidence that the total in-place value of the machinery was $180,990 of which property valued at $34,065 had been moved by appellee to its new location. On August 25, 1976 the Board filed an award of $94,800 for the real estate and $183,425 for dislocation of business damages and moving expenses. On appeal by appellee (the award for the real estate was not contested) the lower court held that the Assembled Economic Unit Doctrine is not applicable where an award is made pursuant to Section 601A of the Eminent Domain Code1 (Code) and that evidence of the in-place value of the machinery or the value of appellee’s property as an As*4sembled Economic Unit is not relevant or admissible in determining damages when machinery or equipment has been moved. We affirm.

Preliminarily we must consider appellee’s motion to quash this appeal on the ground that the order of the court below was not a final order within the meaning of Section 517 of the Code, 26 P.S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.