Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County June 15, 1978, no. 793 (Desiree Mines, Ltd. v. Provident National Bank)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1978
JAMISON, J.,
This matter is before the court on plaintiffs preliminary objections to defendant’s new matter and counterclaim. A complaint in assumpsit was filed by Desiree Mines, Ltd., against Provident National Bank alleging that the bank had paid the proceeds of a $6,900 check, payable to Desiree Mines, Ltd., to plaintiffs president, James L. Wilson, upon Mr. Wilson’s unauthorized endorsement. In its answer, new matter and counterclaim, defendant alleged that Wilson and the other two officers of Desiree conspired to defraud Arsen Kashkashian, the owner of the premises which he had leased to plaintiff. The officers, it is alleged, made a fraudulent claim against the lessor for water damage which they intentionally caused to the premises. The claim was settled for $6,900 and Kashkashian delivered the check in that amount to Wilson. Shortly thereafter, the remaining officers admitted they had defrauded Kashkashian and signed written confessions.
*165Defendant bank avers that the admitted fraud of plaintiffs officers, who, it contends, were acting within the scope of their authority, created a cause of action in Kashkashian, as well as a defense to any suit by Desiree against him for the fund in question. It is argued that Provident, pursuant to section 4-407 of the Uniform Commercial Code of April 6, 1953, P.L. 3, as amended, 12A P.S. §4-407, is subrogated to the rights and defenses of Kash-kashian, the drawer or maker. The counterclaim requests compensatory damages in the amount of $6,900 plus interest from January 30, 1974, punitive damages in an amount in excess of $10,000, as well as costs and counsel fees.
Plaintiff contends that section 4-407 is not applicable because it is limited to situations involving stop payment orders or where the maker or drawer could have a basis for objecting to the payor bank making payment on the check.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit