Court of Appeals of Arizona November 22, 1978, No. 2 CA-CR 1419 (State v. Stambaugh)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-11-1978
OPINION
RICHMOND, Chief Judge.
The determinative question on this appeal is whether the improper conduct of the prosecutor in closing argument deprived appellant of a fair trial, requiring reversal. We hold that it did, but reject appellant’s contention that the evidence was insufficient to support conviction and remand for a new trial.
Appellant was charged with second degree murder and the jury found him guilty of involuntary manslaughter. The charge arose from the death of a two-and-one-half-year-old child entrusted to his care as babysitter. In closing argument, defense counsel told the jury:
[The prosecutor] has tried every which way to get a conviction in this case. He starts out by saying: This murder is intentional. He will show there is some deliberate act with malice.
Now, he is talking about involuntary manslaughter, talking about instructions on involuntary manslaughter.
Sometimes lawyers demand the moon hoping they can get something.
I submit [the prosecutor] is asking for second degree murder hoping he can get involuntary manslaughter from you.
I say to you: If Sammie did all the things [the prosecutor] says, convict him of second degree murder. If he is innocent, free him.
In response, the prosecutor argued:
He says I’m talking about manslaughter; that I’m asking you to convict him of murder, yet I’m giving you a discussion relating to the crime of manslaughter. As [defense counsel] indicated, before we came out here and started final arguments, we sat with the judge, spent the better part of an hour going over the instructions. The fact is [defense counsel] requested an instruction on manslaughter. This is not something that I—
Defense counsel’s objection at this juncture was sustained, and the court announced that the matter would be taken up later outside the presence of the jury. Before that time, at the commencement of the instructions, the court told the jury:
Let me say one thing with reference to the instructions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit