Court of Appeals of Washington March 27, 1978, No. 2054-3 (Beaughan v. Losvar)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1978

Roe, J.

Plaintiffs appeal the dismissal of their wrongful death action against Albert and Isabelle Losvar.

The facts are simple:

While riding a motorcycle, plaintiffs' son, Mitchell, was struck and killed by an automobile operated by Blair Losvar.

Plaintiffs brought suit against Blair and his parents, Albert and Isabelle. At trial Blair and his parents testified that although Blair had been "grounded" on the day the accident occurred, i.e., he was not to use the automobile or leave the family home, while his parents were gone Blair used the automobile and the accident occurred. The jury found Blair liable but his use of the automobile nonpermissive. The court entered judgment against Blair and dismissed the action as to his parents.

Although plaintiffs have urged four sub-assignments of error, the dispositive issue is whether the court should have instructed the jury as follows:

You are further instructed that implied consent may be established by proof that the car was customarily used by Defendant Blair Losvar.

The matter of whether or not Defendant Blair Losvar was obeying his parents' instruction as to the use of the car on a particular occasion does not relieve the parents of responsibility for Defendant Blair Losvar's negligent acts if you find that the car was customarily used by Defendant Blair Losvar.[1]

*595Assuming the plaintiffs (a) properly objected to the court's failure to instruct, and (b) properly proposed the instruction from which the foregoing portion is taken,2 we find no error.

The parameters of the family car doctrine in Washington are well established:

It has also been uniformly held in this state, ever since it was so decided in Birch v. Abercrombie, supra [74 Wash. 486, 133 P.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.