Court of Appeals of Washington August 14, 1978, No. 6060-1 (Petersen v. City of Seattle)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-08-1978

James, J. —

Petitioners were convicted in Seattle Municipal Court of 64 violations of Seattle's "panoram" ordinance.1 Their timely motion to dismiss the charges on the ground that the complaints failed to specify the place where the alleged offenses occurred was denied by the municipal court judge.2

*110After conviction, petitioners sought a writ of certiorari from superior court to review the denial of their motion to dismiss. The order for the writ was issued by a court commissioner and expressly provided that "[petitioners may file notice of appeal in said complaints without prejudice to their writ of certiorari provided they are filed within the statutory time limits." Petitioners thereafter filed a timely notice of appeal. The City did not seek review of the commissioner's order pursuant to RCW 2.24.050.

This appeal is from the superior court order dismissing the writ of certiorari. The trial judge's reason for the dismissal was that " [petitioners have a plain, speedy and adequate remedy at law on trial de novo, as the trial judge on trial de novo may consider and decide the sufficiency of the complaint as it was filed in municipal court." Conclusion of law No. 2.5.

The trial judge orally stated, however, that if on appeal it was determined that the municipal judge's denial of petitioner's motion to dismiss was properly reviewable by cer-tiorari, his ruling would be that the complaints should be dismissed. Accordingly, the trial judge entered formal "alternate" conclusions of law as follows:

3.1— JCrR 2.01 states that a complaint shall set forth the place of the alleged offense.

3.2— In order to state an offense, it is necessary that a complaint contain the address of the alleged offense.

3.3— JCrR 2.04 states that a complaint shall not be deemed insufficient for lack of any matter not necessary to a plain, concise and definite statement of the essential facts constituting a specific offense.

3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.