Oregon Supreme Court March 7, 1978, TC 75-846-L, SC 25323 (Wheeler v. McNett)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-03-1978
TONGUE, J.
In an action for damages for trespass an oral stipulation was made at the time of trial for settlement of the case, consisting of a 12-page colloquy between the parties and their attorneys in which various terms of settlement were discussed. At that time it was agreed that a written stipulation would be "entered into and signed by the parties and their attorneys and an order entered confirming the stipulation and dismissing the action.”
Apparently no such written stipulation was ever "entered into and signed.” One year later defendant’s attorney submitted to the court a "Judgment Per Stipulation,” by the terms of which that oral "stipulation” was "confirmed” and the 12-page "transcript of said stipulation” was "incorporated into this order.” The court "further ordered” not only that "the parties comply with said stipulation,” but that "Plaintiffs execute an easement in favor of the Defendant for the relocated easement” and that if plaintiffs failed to do so "Defendants may submit said easement for the signature of the Court.” Plaintiffs appeal from this judgment. We reverse.
Upon examination of the 12-page "stipulation,” we find that it was not limited to the execution by plaintiffs of an easement to defendant along a route marked upon a map which was marked as an exhibit but not attached to the transcript so as to be part of the judgment. There was also discussion of various other matters, including the maintenance of a road along the easement. According to the transcript, defendant was to be responsible for maintenance of the "upper part of the road,” but the cost of maintenance of "the part of the road used by both parties* * * down to east of the dam,” was to be "shared equally,” as distinguished from "the part of the road used largely by one party or the other.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit