Court of Appeals of Oregon March 13, 1978, No. 418-201, CA 8519 (Scenic Sites, Inc. v. Board of County Commissioners)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1978

BUTTLER, J.

This writ of review proceeding challenges an order issued by the Multnomah County Board of County Commissioners conditionally approving a street created "for the purpose of partitioning a parcel of land” pursuant to ORS 92.014,1 as said order was modified by the circuit court.2 Our opinion in a prior appeal, Scenic Sites v. Multnomah County Comm., 27 Or App 831, 557 P2d 678 (1976), stated the facts succinctly:

"At some time prior to 1974 [sic, 1973] the following events took place: Scenic Sites, Inc. (Scenic), acquired a tract of land comprised of approximately 45 acres. Scenic partitioned this tract of land into seven parcels, each with access to a gravel road which had served previously as a logging road. Six of the parcels did not abut a public road. After partition, Scenic conveyed all seven parcels to various individuals. Thereafter the county denied individual parcel owners septic permits on the grounds that the partition was illegal in that there had not been prior approval of the road (the existing logging road) created for the purposes of partition, as required by ORS 92.014. In response to this objection, Scenic divided the road longitudinally into seven strips and conveyed a strip to each parcel owner so that a narrow finger of land or "dogleg” connected each parcel with the nearest public road. Apparently, Scenic retained no interest in any portion of the road or any other part of the original 45 acres.

*202"The road was evidently conveyed on the theory that no road would exist within the meaning of ORS 92.014 if none of the parcels were land-locked — that is, if each parcel had some minimal physical contact with a public road. Despite this device, the county refused to grant building permits to individual parcel owners, again citing noncompliance with ORS 92.014. Accordingly, Scenic applied to the county planning commission to have the road approved. The commission recommended approval subject to certain conditions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.