Court of Appeals of Oregon June 13, 1978, No. 06-77-192, CA 9829 (Stone v. Oregon State Penitentiary)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-06-1978

LEE, J.

This is a petition for judicial review of a final disciplinary order of the Superintendent of the Oregon State Penitentiary.

Initially petitioner was charged with, and found guilty of, committing three rule violations. The recommended sanction was approved by the superintendent on July 1, 1977. Petitioner filed for judicial review which was dismissed pursuant to stipulation.

A new hearing was held in November, 1977. The first page of the "REPORT OF VIOLATION OF INSTITUTION RULES,” which shows the procedure followed at the hearing, notes that petitioner pled not guilty to three violations and that petitioner was found guilty. The identical punishment initially imposed was again recommended.

Petitioner contends that the disciplinary committee erred in noting its guilty finding on the charge sheet as though it applied to the three rule violations initially charged when, in fact, he was found guilty of only one violation. The state concedes that this assignment of error is well taken. Accordingly, this case is remanded with directions that the finding entered under "DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE ACTION” be corrected to reflect that the other charges were dismissed and that the committee found petitioner guilty of conspiracy only.

Further, petitioner contends that the disciplinary action taken should be remanded for reconsideration by the superintendent because the form of the guilty finding may have misled him in his evaluation of the sanction.

OAR 291-40-125(1) provides that the superintendent shall review each disciplinary action and enter an order which may:

"(a) Affirm the disposition imposed by the disciplinary committee; or

*738"(b) Modify the disposition imposed by the disciplinary committee; or

"(c) Reverse the conclusion of the disciplinary committee; or

"(d) Increase the sanction imposed by the disciplinary committee.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.