Appellate Court of Illinois October 12, 1978, No. 14793 (Union Electric Co. v. Illinois Commerce Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-1978

lead-opinion

Mr. JUSTICE CRAVEN

delivered the opinion of the court:

The Illinois Commerce Commission (Commission) and certain industrial intervenors timely appeal the trial court’s decision remanding the cause to the Commission for reconsideration based on the court’s finding that the Commission acted outside the scope of its authority in both determining “value” for rate purposes and setting a rate of return primarily based on a decision of the Missouri Public Service Commission. Due to the substantial issues involved, the facts in the record will be detailed in some length.

On February 11, 1975, Union Electric (UE) filed a tariff with the Commission seeking a general rate increase. Numerous hearings were held between April 11, 1975, and December 16,1975, when the case was submitted to the Commission after oral argument. On January 9,1976, the Commission filed its order determining the adjusted original cost rate base for UE’s property allocated to Illinois operations to be *197,173,000. The Commission also found a return of approximately 7.83% applied to the rate base (yielding operating income of some *15,429,000) to be fair, just, and reasonable. UE’s application for rehearing was denied by the Commission on February 18, 1976.

Union Electric, a Missouri corporation, generates and sells electric energy in Missouri, Iowa, and Illinois. It serves three areas in Illinois, including an area near Keokuk, Iowa, and the cities of East St. Louis and Alton. The Illinois service area has a population of about 262,000, while UE’s Missouri and Iowa service areas have estimated populations of 1.943.000 and 47,000, respectively. The bulk of the company’s 739,000 electric customers are in Missouri; there are 70,000 Illinois customers, and 16.000 in Iowa.

During the hearings, UE tendered evidence of two proposed rate bases.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.