Appellate Court of Illinois December 14, 1978, Nos. 77-508, 77-661 cons. (Ramos v. Local Liquor Control Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-1978

Mr. JUSTICE ROMITI

delivered the opinion of the court:

The sole issue in this case is whether the appellant, whose license to operate a tavern was revoked after a hearing, was denied due process because he was denied access to the report of the hearing examiner. We find no due process violation and affirm.

Ramos was charged by the Chicago Local Liquor Control Commission with aggravated battery and possession of an unregistered gun on licensed premises. There was a lengthy evidentiary hearing before deputy commissioner Handy. After this hearing, the mayor, acting as Local Liquor Control Commissioner (Commissioner) revoked Ramos’ license. Ramos appealed to the local License Appeal Commission. One of his contentions there was that Handy’s report, if any, to the Commissioner should be put in the record. This request was denied and the order of revocation affirmed.

Ramos then filed a complaint in the circuit court, alleging on information and belief that Handy had, after hearing all of the evidence, recommended disposition other than revocation and seeking production of the specific finding or recommendation. The circuit court first granted this motion, then, on rehearing, denied it. Ramos then sought unsuccessfully to subpoena Handy. After arguments the circuit court affirmed the license revocation.

The appellant has not set forth any of the testimony produced at the hearing, nor has the appellant contended on appeal to this court that that testimony does not support the Commissioner’s determination. What he does contend is the circuit court deprived him of a full and complete hearing on administrative review, by denying him the opportunity to make an evidentiary showing, by way of discovery or by way of testimony, that the trier of fact had judged credibility in his favor.

I.

To determine whether the appellant has been denied due process, it is essential to consider the relationship between the hearing examiner and the Commissioner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.