Louisiana Court of Appeal May 1, 1978, No. 11927 (Hinchen v. Fontenot Construction Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-1978

LANDRY, Judge.

Defendants J. E. Fontenot General Contractor, Inc. (Employer) and Employer’s insurer, St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company, (Appellants), appeal from judgment dismissing their exception of prescription and awarding plaintiff (Appellee) workmen’s compensation benefits after trial on the merits. We reverse and render judgment sustaining Appellants’ exception of prescription and dismissing Appellee’s claim with prejudice.

The facts are undisputed. Appellee was injured August 4,1972 when he fell from a carpenter’s scaffold in the course and scope of his employment by Employer. Employer corporation, whose address is Route 7, Box 615-B, is for all practical purposes owned by J. E. Fontenot, who runs the corporation from the stated location which is also his home address. St. Paul paid Appellee compensation from the date of the accident until April 25, 1973, on which date payments were terminated. Appellee never resumed work for Employer. On May 25, 1973, Appellants tendered a written offer of compromise to Appellee’s attorney in the sum of $4,000.00.

On April 8, 1974, Appellee instituted suit on his compensation claim against Fontenot Construction Company and its alleged insurer, Hartford Indemnity Company. Service on Fontenot Construction Company was requested to be made at 633 Oak Villa Boulevard, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and on Hartford through the Secretary of State. Fontenot Construction is wholly owned by Emery J. Fontenot, who is no relation to J. E. Fontenot. Service of plaintiff’s petition was made on Emery J. Fontenot April 11, 1974. On May 11,1974, a letter bearing the signature of Emery J. Fontenot, on Fonten-ot’s letterhead, was sent to Appellee’s attorney, advising him that the citation was not for Fontenot Construction Company.

On May 1, 1975, Appellee amended his petition, substituting Employer and St. Paul as defendants. Domiciliary service was made on Employer on May 5,1975, and on St.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.