Louisiana Court of Appeal December 4, 1978, No. 13696 (Montgomery v. American Fire & Indemnity Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1978

JONES, Judge.

Plaintiffs, husband and wife, brought this action on November 10, 1977 against defendant, American Fire and Indemnity Company, for damages arising from an automobile accident which occurred on November 17, 1976, which they allege was due to the negligence of the defendant’s insured. The plaintiff-wife was injured in the accident while driving a community automobile which was damaged in the accident.

Plaintiff-wife sues for her loss of wages in the amount of $5,423.20. Plaintiff-husband also sues for his lost wages of $2,000 which he failed to earn during the time he stayed at home and cared for his injured wife.

Defendant filed a motion for summary judgment alleging plaintiffs split their cause of action, which is prohibited by *202C.C.P. Article 4251 because they filed a prior suit for damages arising out of the same accident on August 17, 1977 against American Fire and Indemnity Company and John H. Lewis.

In the prior suit, plaintiff-husband, as head and master of the community, asked for the following damages: property damage to automobile, $500; past and future medical expenses for wife, $6,051.25; past and future loss of wages for wife, $10,000. Plaintiff-wife asked for $100,000 damages for her personal injuries. On the second and last day of the prior trial, defendants filed an exception of no right of action directed at the husband’s suit for his wife’s lost wages based upon C.C.P. Article 6862 which provides the wife is the proper party plaintiff to sue for her loss of wages. The trial judge sustained the defendant’s exception of no right of action. The husband was not permitted to prove the wife’s loss of wages. A judgment was therein rendered pursuant to a jury verdict of $750 for the husband and $2,500 for the wife.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.