Supreme Court of Colorado November 27, 1978, No. 27766 (People ex rel. Kuiper v. DeHerrera)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-11-1978
MR. JUSTICE KELLEY
delivered the opinion of the Court.
*482This is an appeal from an order granting a summary judgment to the People of the State of Colorado ex rel. C. J. Kuiper and D. H. McFadden, appellees, (collectively referred to as the State), plaintiffs in the trial court, enjoining the appellants, Peter L. DeHerrera and Augustine J. DeHerrera, defendants in the trial court, from using their decreed water to irrigate land located outside of Sections 25 and 30, Township 33 North, Range 10 East, of the New Mexico Principal Meridian, and outside the watershed of the San Antonio River. The trial court found that there was no genuine issue of material fact and granted summary judgment. A review of the record discloses that there are genuine issues as to material facts which should be resolved. Therefore, we reverse and remand for trial.
Peter L. DeHerrera and his brother Augustine DeHerrera each own an undivided quarter interest in the Lovato Irrigation Ditch, which is Ditch No. 31, Priority No. 33, as of June 14, 1867 (referred to as Lovato Ditch or Lovato Water). The volume or quantity of water is not material to the issues.
In 1968, Peter L. DeHerrera obtained a permit from the state engineer to change the decreed point of diversion to the headgate of the Teodora Ditch No. 2. In issuing the permit, the state engineer specifically found:
“That the diversion [granted by the permit] ... at an alternate or supplemental point of diversion which is the headgate of the Teodora Ditch No. 2 . . . will not adversely affect the rights of other appropriators on said San Antonio River, and will be used to apply water to land currently being irrigated under said decree and is necessary to the beneficial use of water by applicant, Peter L. DeHerrera.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit