Michigan Supreme Court October 2, 1978, Docket No. 61161 (Macarthur Patton Christian Ass'n v. Farm Bureau Insurance Group)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-10-1978

Per Curiam.

The issue raised by the plaintiff’s application for leave to appeal is whether the trial judge abused her discretion in granting defendant’s motion to dismiss for failure of an agent of plaintiff to appear at his deposition. We conclude that the dismissal was an abuse of discretion.

I

The plaintiff commenced this action on September 21, 1976 seeking to recover on an insurance policy issued by the defendant for the alleged theft of certain cattle owned by the plaintiff. The defendant denied liability on the ground that the theft, if there was one, was by an employee of the plaintiff and thus within a policy exclusion. Various discovery proceedings were undertaken and on April 14, 1977 the defendant filed a notice of taking the deposition of Renato Varani, an agent of the plaintiff. The deposition was noticed for May 2, 1977 at 11 a.m. On the morning of May 2, the secretary for plaintiff’s attorney called the defendant’s attorney and told him that the plaintiff’s attorney was ill and requested an adjournment of the deposition. The defendant’s attorney agreed to an adjournment and the next day renoticed the *476deposition for May 11, 1977 at 2 p.m. On the morning of May 11, the secretary for the plaintiffs attorney again called the defendant’s attorney and informed him that neither she nor the plaintiffs attorney had been able to contact Mr. Varani and that neither Mr. Varani nor the plaintiffs attorney would be present at the scheduled deposition. The defendant’s attorney said that he would be present at the scheduled time and expected the deponent to appear. Neither the deponent nor the plaintiffs attorney appeared for the deposition, and the defendant filed a motion to dismiss under GCR 1963, 313.4.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.