United States Court of Claims February 22, 1978, No. 206-75 (Winter & Hirsch, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-1978

*519This tax refund suit is before the court on defendant’s motion for partial summary judgment. Plaintiff claims it is entitled to an additional deduction in fiscal year 1963 of $661,386.28 as a reasonable addition to its bad debts reserve on account of debts which admittedly became worthless in prior taxable years. Defendant maintains plaintiff is not so entitled. After careful consideration of the briefs and oral arguments, we grant defendant’s motion for partial summary judgment.

The plaintiff is a corporation which ceased doing active business in 1970. Prior to that time, plaintiff was in the business of making consumer loans, primarily to finance consumer purchases of automobiles. At all relevant times plaintiff filed its federal income tax returns on the basis of a fiscal year ending August 31 and used the reserve for bad debts method to compute its deduction for bad debts.

At some time after 1969 plaintiff discovered that certain debts owed to it, which had become worthless in periods prior to the 1963 taxable year and which had been charged off in its underlying records during those periods, had not been taken into account for tax purposes either as deductions or in computing taxpayer’s bad debts reserve. These debts, amounting to at least $661,386.28,1 were not taken into account for tax purposes by reason of a scheme to defraud which had been perpetrated upon plaintiff by its key officers from 1957 to 1969 with the active cooperation of the certified public accountants retained during that time.

On October 15, 1970, taxpayer timely filed claims for refund for its 1960, 1961, and 1962 taxable years on the ground that it had overpaid its taxes for those years as a result of a net operating loss carryback from its 1963 taxable year. The alleged 1963 net operating loss resulted from an increased bad debts deduction to which taxpayer claims it is entitled. Taxpayer asserts that its bad debt deduction for 1963 should be increased by $661,386.28, from $671,541.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.