U.S. Army Court of Military Review July 6, 1978, CM 436196 (United States v. Otero)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-07-1978

OPINION OF THE COURT

JONES, Senior Judge:

The appellant comes before this Court convicted of assault with a dangerous weapon in violation of Article 128, Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 U.S.C. § 928. The convening authority approved the sentence of a bad-conduct discharge, confinement at hard labor for four months, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and reduction to Private E-l. We are reviewing the case pursuant to Article 66, UCMJ.

This ease concerns the issue of illegal pretrial confinement. The appellant contends his commander did not follow the stepped-process delineated in United States v. Heard, 3 M.J. 14 (C.M.A.1977), in that a lesser form of restraint was not first “tried and . . . found wanting . . ” before confinement was imposed. The confinement, he argues, was thus illegal.1 Ancillary questions concern the scope of review of the issue at this level and the nature of the hearing and the standard of proof at the trial level.

The appellant was placed in pretrial confinement at the direction of his battalion commander, after making a statement to Army criminal investigators about his involvement in the stabbing of a fellow soldier in barracks. He remained in confinement for 65 days until trial. During that period a military magistrate reviewed appellant’s confinement and determined that he should remain confined.

At trial, the appellant raised the issue of illegal pretrial confinement and asked for appropriate sentence relief. In support of his motion, he personally, and his company commander by way of stipulation, testified to the existence of pretrial confinement. *777The Government in response called the battalion commander who made the decision to confine and to continue such confinement during the processing of the case.

The battalion commander testified at length as to the considerations that went into his decisions to confine and to continue confinement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.