District Court, D. Minnesota May 30, 1978, No. 3-78 Civ. 196 (Dakota Wholesale Liquor, Inc. v. Minnesota)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-05-1978
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
DEVITT, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff moves for a preliminary injunction which would stay the effective date of a recently enacted Minnesota statute and would require defendants, other than the State of Minnesota, to sell their products to plaintiff pending trial on the merits. Plaintiff’s motion is denied.
Plaintiff is a South Dakota corporation licensed in South Dakota and Minnesota as a wholesaler of alcoholic beverages. Defendants, other than the State of Minnesota, are manufacturers of alcoholic beverages. Plaintiff has engaged in an ingenious system of obtaining and marketing alcohol. Because of Minnesota’s “non-discrimination” statute with regard to alcoholic beverages, plaintiff through its Minnesota wholesaler’s license can obtain any and all brands of alcohol that it wishes. Plaintiff then “transships” much of this alcohol to South Dakota for resale to South Dakota retailers, thus circumventing the exclusive distributorship liquor distribution system in effect in South Dakota and at least tacitly approved by the South Dakota legislature. Two snags have developed in plaintiff’s system, however, and they have resulted in this litigation.
The defendant manufacturers, because of the actual and potential disruptive effect plaintiff’s plan has on their marketing operations in states with exclusive distributorship systems, have refused to sell liquor to plaintiff as a Minnesota wholesaler if plaintiff intends to transship the liquor out of Minnesota. Defendants have all represented, however, that they will continue to sell to plaintiff for resale in Minnesota. Plaintiff asserts that this refusal to sell was taken by defendants in concert, thus resulting in a group boycott in violation of § 1 of the Sherman Act.
The second snag plaintiff has encountered concerns the Act of March 28, 1978, ch. 687, § 3, 1978 Minn.Sess. Law Serv. (West) 451.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit