Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Pike County May 22, 1978, no. 89 (Wright v. Wright)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-05-1978
THOMSON, J.,
In the above matter, plaintiff, William F. Wright, Jr., petitioned the court to modify a property settlement agreement heretofore entered into between the parties. Hearing was held and testimony taken on April 17, 1978. Thereafter, briefs were filed.
Two questions are presented to the court for determination at this time: (1) Does the court have the power to modify the property settlement agreement which is the subject matter of this litigation; (2) and, if so, has plaintiff demonstrated such a change of circumstances as would make modification of such agreement appropriate. We will address ourselves to the first of these questions at this time.
Defendant contends that absent fraud, duress, or undue influence a voluntary separation and support agreement such as the one which is the subject matter of this litigation may not be modified by the court. In support of her position, defendant has cited the case of Schoble v. Schoble, 349 Pa. 408, 37 A. 2d 604 (1944). We find this case to be little sup*116port for this position. The Schoble case represented an attempt by petitioner to completely void a voluntary agreement by supposed reasons of fraud and undue influence by respondent wife and her attorney. The lower court granted petitioner’s request stating that it felt that the agreement was so grossly unjust and unfair that it should be voided. The Superior Court, in rejecting this holding, stated that it would not render a voluntary agreement void due to unfairness and unreasonableness absent a showing of undue influence, duress, or fraud. The court further concluded that the evidence was to the contrary in that case.
The precise question now before the court does not seem to have been directly dealt with by the appellate courts of Pennsylvania. However, a number of cases cited by plaintiff give us some insight into this matter. For example, the case of Com. ex rel. Colligan v. Kass, 225 Pa. Superior Ct. 299, 303 A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit