Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Monroe County June 5, 1978, nos. 67 and 68 of 1978 (Commonwealth v. Wright)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-06-1978
THOMSON J.,
Defendants Wright and Draper, in the above-captioned matters, have filed various pre-trial motions with the court, including, inter aha, motions to quash the magistrate’s return of preliminary hearing, and applications to suppress various physical evidence seized against defendants. These motions are now before the court for determination.
I. DEFENDANT WRIGHT’S MOTION TO QUASH THE MAGISTRATE’S RETURN OF PRELIMINARY HEARING
Two preliminary hearings were held on the charges against defendant Wright, one taking place on November 1, 1977, and the other on December 15, 1977. It has been stipulated by counsel that the court will decide the merits of this motion, and the companion motion filed on behalf of defendant Draper, based on the notes of testimony of said hearings.
It is time-honored law in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania that at a preliminary hearing, just as at a hearing in the nature of a habeas corpus, the Commonwealth must produce evidence that would constitute “sufficient probable cause to believe, that the person charged has committed the offense stated,” that is, the Commonwealth must make out a prima facie case of guilt against defendant: Com. ex rel. Scolio v. Hess, 149 Pa. Superior Ct. 371, 27 A. 2d 705 (1942). It is not necessary at such pro*336ceedings that the Commonwealth produce evidence so as to require a finding by a jury of the guilt of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt, as a preliminary hearing, just as a proceeding in a nature of habeas corpus is not a trial.
Applying the standards set forward above to the instant proceedings, we will examine the evidence against defendant Wright in order to determine whether the magistrate’s return, which indicated a primafacie case on all charges, those of conspiracy, theft of telecommunications services, and manufacture, possession or distribution of devices for theft of telecommunications services should be quashed. . . .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit