Michigan Supreme Court June 18, 1979, 60422, (Calendar No. 7) (Powell v. Casco Nelmor Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1979

combined-opinion

406 Mich. 332 (1979) 279 N.W.2d 769 POWELL v. CASCO NELMOR CORPORATION Docket No. 60422, (Calendar No. 7). Supreme Court of Michigan. Argued November 15, 1978. Decided June 18, 1979. Sommers, Schwartz, Silver & Schwartz, P.C. (by Robert F. Auld and Richard D. Toth), for plaintiff. Salisbury, Ciampa & Franco for defendants. *339 WILLIAMS, J. Leave to appeal was granted to determine whether a worker who suffered a work-related hand injury is entitled to compensation under the following circumstances: (1) the worker obtained a redemption for a subsequent cancer claim; (2) the worker after the hand injury but prior to the discovery of her cancer was given favored work at wages equal to or higher than her wages prior to the hand injury; and (3) an operation resulting from the cancer made the worker more sensitive to the pollutants in her place of work and hence unable to continue to work and earn wages at her previous favored work. We hold as follows: (1) the redemption both in fact and legally was not related to a work injury. Hence, there is no duplication between it and the workers' compensation for the hand injury which was work-related. Consequently, the redemption does not affect the worker's right to compensation. (2) So long as a worker is receiving wages at favored work equal to or higher than his or her wages prior to injury, the worker is not entitled to compensation. The receipt of wages for favored work, however, does not establish a wage-earning capacity and hence does not modify the right to compensation for a prior injury when favored work is no longer available. (3) A supervening event, not chargeable to the worker, which makes it impossible for the worker to continue his or her previous favored work does not preclude the payment of compensation for a prior injury. We, therefore, hold that there is no legal basis on which to preclude payment of the plaintiff's compensation in this case. The WCAB and the Court of Appeals are reversed. I.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.