Supreme Court of Georgia September 10, 1979, 35115 (First American Bank v. Bishop)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1979

Hill, Justice.

Lamar Bishop was the maker of several promissory notes to the First American Bank. His father, Alton Bishop, the plaintiff in this case, signed separate guaranties on the notes. Lamar Bishop was adjudicated bankrupt in early 1975, discharging him on a $26,474.90 debt owed the bank. Subsequently, both Bishops signed a promissory note and plaintiff Alton Bishop signed a separate guaranty as to Lamar Bishop’s debts to the bank.

Alton Bishop brought an action in equity to cancel the last note and guaranty signed by him in face amounts

*318

of $26,474.90 each and seeking punitive damages and attorney fees. Plaintiff alleged fraud and confidential relationship. The bank’s motion for summary judgment was denied and that order was affirmed on appeal.

First American Bank v. Bishop,

239 Ga. 809 (239 SE2d 19) (1977). At trial, the jury found for plaintiff as to cancellation of the note and guaranty and awarded him $10,000 in attorney fees. The trial court entered judgment cancelling plaintiffs obligations to the bank. The bank appeals, enumerating three errors, including the sufficiency of the evidence.

1. The plaintiffs evidence presented at trial was as follows: Plaintiffs daughter-in-law’s brother was senior vice-president of the bank. Plaintiff had guaranteed his son’s loans from the bank. After the son went bankrupt, the vice-president called plaintiff to come into the bank the last week in April, 1975, at which time plaintiff signed a blank promissory note. According to plaintiff it was agreed between them that the note would be filled in for $5,000.

The next week plaintiff returned to the bank. The bank officer filled out a financial statement based on plaintiffs answers to certain questions and it was agreed that plaintiff would pay $100 per month on the $5, 000 note. Plaintiff said that he would prefer to pay $1,200 for a year in advance rather than $100 per month.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.