Court of Appeals of North Carolina December 18, 1979, 7926SC360 (Branch Banking and Trust Co. v. Creasy)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-12-1979
combined-opinion
260 S.E.2d 782 (1979) 44 N.C. App. 289 BRANCH BANKING AND TRUST COMPANY v. Margaret W. CREASY. No. 7926SC360. Court of Appeals of North Carolina. December 18, 1979. *783 Murchison & Guthrie by Alton G. Murchison, III, Charlotte, for plaintiff-appellee. Stack & Stephens by Warren C. Stack, Charlotte, for defendant-appellant. HARRY C. MARTIN, Judge. We hold the entry of summary judgment for plaintiff was error. The rules and procedures governing motions for summary judgment should now be familiar learning. They are well expressed in Kessing v. Mortgage Corp., 278 N.C. 523, 180 S.E.2d 823 (1971), and it would serve no useful purpose to restate them here. Plaintiff on the hearing for summary judgment produced the guaranty, admittedly signed by defendant. Then, through the witnesses Miller and Margaret Creasy, plaintiff produced evidence showing nondelivery of the guaranty by defendant, or her attorney Miller, to plaintiff. The evidence of Miller and Mrs. Creasy raises a reasonable inference that the guaranty was stolen by Tom Creasy, signed by him and then returned by him to the bank. Miller testified at one place in the record he intended to cause the guaranty to be delivered to the bank, but at another place he says it was not his intention for the bank to obtain the document. At any rate, he did not deliver or cause the guaranty to be delivered to the bank. Rather, he placed it with other papers relating to the controversy between *784 defendant and her husband where it remained for eleven days. The record is unclear as to how the bank got possession of the paper; Tyler testified the executed guaranty was "returned" to him on 18 November 1975, which indicates that he had possession of the executed guaranty prior to that date. Nondelivery of a negotiable instrument is a defense to an action upon it. N.C.Gen. Stat. 25-3-306(c).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit