California Supreme Court January 19, 1979, S.F. 23858 (Kowalski v. Shell Oil Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-01-1979

Opinion

BIRD, C. J.

Plaintiff, Thomas L. Kowalski, appeals from a judgment entered in favor of defendant, Shell Oil Company, in an action for personal injuries. Following trial, the juiy returned a verdict in favor of plaintiff but the trial court granted Shell’s motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict. This court must decide whether there was substantial evidence to support the juiy’s finding that plaintiff was not Shell Oil Company’s special employee.

I

On May 21, 1969, the C. Norman Peterson Company (Peterson) and Shell entered into a contract whereby Peterson agreed to perform maintenance work at Shell’s refinery in Martinez. The agreement, set forth in a Shell purchase order, provided in pertinent part:

“This order, including instructions and conditions on the reverse side hereof, shall constitute an agreement to cover the furnishing by you [Peterson] of all necessary tools and equipment, materials, labor and supervision (and including the costs of workmen’s compensation and/or employer’s liability insurance and all payroll taxes on such labor) to perform work as follows:

“It is Shell’s intent to establish a ‘general and special employment relationship’ whereby the contractor [Peterson] remains the general employer of its employees and Shell becomes their special employer....

“1. Performance: Contractor shall diligently and carefully perform all work required hereunder in a good and workmanlike manner, shall

*172

furnish all labor, supervision, machinery, materials, equipment and supplies necessary therefor and, if permitted to subcontract, shall be fully responsible for all work and services performed by subcontractors. Contractor shall conduct all operations in Contractor’s own name as an independent contractor and not in the name of, or as agent for, Shell.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.