Court of Appeals of Kansas January 5, 1979, 49,496 (Southgate State Bank & Trust Co. v. United Pacific Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-01-1979

combined-opinion

3 Kan. App. 2d 37 (1979) 588 P.2d 486 SOUTHGATE STATE BANK AND TRUST COMPANY, a Kansas Banking Corporation, Appellee and Cross-Appellant, v. UNITED PACIFIC INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant and Cross-Appellee. No. 49,496 Court of Appeals of Kansas. Opinion filed January 5, 1979. James W. Bouska, of Bouska & Allen, of Overland Park, and Bernard L. Balkin, of Kansas City, Missouri, for the appellant and cross-appellee. Fred J. Logan, Jr., and Thomas H. Bornholdt, of Cooke, North, Dickson & Bornholdt, Chartered, of Prairie Village, for the appellee and cross-appellant. Before PARKS, P.J., SWINEHART and MEYER, JJ. PARKS, J.: Plaintiff, Southgate State Bank and Trust Company, is insured under two liability insurance bonds. Primary coverage by Kansas Bankers Surety Company insures plaintiff up to $25,000, while defendant, United Pacific Insurance Company, insures plaintiff against liability in excess of $25,000 but less than $1,675,000. Except for the deductibles and limits of coverage, the language of relevant portions of both bonds is identical. Reasonable legal expenses may be incurred in defense actions under the provisions of both policies. The present controversy arose when a $407,000 third-party complaint was filed against the bank. Both insurers were notified of the suit. The primary insurer agreed to defend the plaintiff but the defendant excess insurer refused. Apparently fearing an excessive judgment, the plaintiff bank retained private counsel to assist the primary insurer in its defense of the suit. The claim against the bank was settled for $12,500; subsequently the bank initiated this action seeking to recover attorney fees expended both in defending the third-party complaint and in bringing the recovery action itself. Although the Johnson County district court entered summary judgment for the plaintiff bank, it denied plaintiff's prayer for costs and fees in the recovery action. Defendant appeals and plaintiff cross-appeals.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.