Utah Supreme Court April 23, 1979, 15875 (Petty v. Utah State Board of Regents)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-04-1979

CROCKETT, Chief Justice:

Charles N. Petty, a student in the medical school at the University of Utah, filed this

*1300

action,

1

to restrain the defendants from assessing $105 in student’s fees as part of the medical school tuition for the school year 1976-77.

Upon issues joined in the pleadings, and pursuant to discovery proceedings, it appeared that there was no dispute as to material facts. Both parties moved for summary judgment. The district court granted defendants’ motion and plaintiff appeals.

The Board of Regents established medical school tuition rates of $1,450 for resident students and $3,000 for nonresident students. In addition, the Board of Regents assessed a student fee of $105 for both resident and nonresident students.

Plaintiff takes the position that the $105 student fee was not lawfully fixed, grounded on Item 91 in Chapter 37 of the Appropriations Act of 1976 (effective April 1, 1976) which states:

He argues that this expression of intent is controlling over any other powers conferred upon the defendants to set tuition.

The district court rejected plaintiff’s contention and in its memorandum decision stated:

It is the opinion of the Court that Item 91 of Chapter 37 of the Appropriations Act of 1976 did not repeal, modify or amend 53-48-10 U.C.A.1953, and that under the latter section the Regents had the authority to set the tuition, fees and charges which it did for students at the College of Medicine for the school year 1976-1977.

Plaintiff urges that an inquiry into the legislative background of this appropriations act will show that the legislature intended that the students of the college of medicine pay a comparatively high tuition to cover revenues lost from other sources (federal grants) and that the fee thus set in the appropriations was intended to be the maximum tuition charge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.