District Court, W.D. Missouri September 21, 1979, Civ. A. 77-CV-0080-W-3 (Doores v. McNamara)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-09-1979

ORDER

RUSSELL G. CLARK, District Judge.

Plaintiff, William Doores filed a complaint pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 on February 3, 1977 against former members of the Board of Police Commissioners, Ilus Davis, John Gibson, Faye S. Werner, Edward Bivens and Charles Wheeler, and the former Chief of Police, Joseph McNamara. Plaintiff alleged that the defendants wilfully and wrongfully refused to reemploy plaintiff as a police officer while employing less qualified individuals classified as minorities.

Jury trial of the above cause of action commenced on Wednesday September 12, 1979 at 9:00 a. m. At the conclusion of the evidence, after hearing argument on defendants’ motion for a directed verdict, the court directed a verdict for all defendants. In directing the verdict pursuant to Rule 50(a) of the FRCP the court set forth three basis for its ruling: 1. Assuming actionable conduct plaintiff had failed to demonstrate the requisite personal involvement of these defendants. 2. The defendants had demonstrated they were entitled to rely on the doctrine of qualified immunity. 3. Plaintiffs had not demonstrated that the employment practices violated the Equal Protection Clause. In an effort to provide the parties with a more detailed and comprehensive explanation of its reasons for directing a verdict, the court is issuing this memorandum opinion supplementing its remarks of September 14, 1979.

Findings of Fact

Evidence presented at trial established the following:

1. Plaintiff Doores resigned from the Kansas City, Missouri Police Department on June 11, 1975 with an effective date of June 24, 1975, last day on the payroll July 3, 1975, having been employed by thé Police Department since March 16, 1962.

2. In September or early October 1975, William J. Doores made initial inquiries concerning possible re-employment with the Kansas City, Missouri Police Department at the rank of police officer.

3. William J.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.