Court of Appeals of Georgia May 14, 1979, 57675 (Bradfield v. Gardner)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1979

Quillian, Presiding Judge.

The plaintiff brought this action in the State Court of DeKalb alleging that the defendant was indebted to the plaintiff in the sum of $895 for purchase money paid to the defendant upon a 1969 Volkswagen automobile, the automobile having been returned to the defendant. The complaint further alleged that the plaintiff through her attorney made demand upon the defendant for the return of the purchase price but the sum had not been returned and the demand had been refused. The case was heard before a trial judge sitting without a jury who entered the judgment finding "that the plaintiff has not carried the burden of proof showing sufficient breach of warranty to allow plaintiff to return the 1969 Volkswagen automobile and recover the purchase price thereof, though the plaintiff has sought to return the said automobile by leaving same at defendant’s residence.” The trial judge found, as a conclusion of law, "the plaintiff not having carried the necessary legal burden, judgment is found in favor of defendant.” Appeal was taken by the plaintiff.

The plaintiffs enumerations of error contain two grounds: 1) the lower court erred in entering judgment against the plaintiff without finding the facts specially and stating separately its conclusions of law; 2) the lower court erred in entering judgment against the plaintiff since the uncontroverted evidence demanded the conclusion that the defendant had consented to the rescission of the contract by retaining the automobile without offering to return it.

Held:

On the trial of the case the plaintiff sought to show that the defendant had breached his warranty to guarantee the motor and transmission of the vehicle for sixty days. There was evidence showing that the vehicle had been returned to the defendant who had kept it since that time without either offering to return the vehicle or

*50

the purchase price.

Submitted April 5, 1979

Decided May 14, 1979.

Clein & Heimanson, Neil L. Heimanson, Harvey A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.