Court of Appeals of Arizona March 13, 1979, 1 CA-CIV 3938 (Koehler v. Koehler)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-03-1979
OPINION
SCHROEDER, Presiding Judge.
This is an appeal from an order permanently enjoining appellants, Melvin and Thelma Koehler, from attempting to contact or communicate with their young granddaughter. The order was entered at the request of their son, appellee, Gary Leigh Koehler, the child’s father. The case involves a question of first impression in Arizona regarding the respective rights of parents and grandparents.
The child, Shannon Koehler, was born in 1969. Shortly thereafter, her parents were divorced. Nine days after the child’s birth, she was delivered to appellants, Gary’s parents, who cared for her in their home for the next several years. During at least some portion of those years, between 1969 and 1974, appellee Gary Koehier also resided in that home. The parties throughout that period had an informal understanding that Gary would take physical custody of the child when he had a suitable home for her.
In November of 1974, Gary took Shannon for a visit and refused to return her to his parents. The appellants immediately sought a temporary injunction returning the child to their home. The court issued this injunction which was enforced by sheriff’s deputies who took Shannon away from her father and returned her to the appellants. This was one of numerous incidents reflected in the record, including a physical tussel over the child, demonstrating the bitterness which had developed between Gary Koehler and his parents.
In January, 1975, the appellants filed a petition seeking exclusive legal custody of the child. In June, 1975, Gary took Shannon from appellants’ home to his own. Since that time the girl has lived with her father. In September, 1975, after an informal hearing, the appellants were advised that the child’s permanent legal and physical custody would be placed with Gary. In December, 1975, Melvin and Thelma Koehler filed a motion requesting a hearing to resolve the question of their visitation rights.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit