Court of Appeals of Texas January 18, 1979, 8192 (Clemtex, Ltd. v. Dube)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-1979

DIES, Chief Justice.

Plaintiff below, Edmund N. Dube, sued Richard Lewis, Joseph Landos, James D. Scott, and Clemtex, Ltd. for damages occasioned by an automobile accident in which he received personal injuries and his wife was killed.

Dube settled with Lewis and Landos for $160,000, agreeing to pay them fifty percent of any damages recovered from Scott and Clemtex, up to $160,000. This agreement was made known to the jury. Clem-tex and Scott kept Lewis and Landos in the lawsuit as parties defendant.

The jury found Clemtex and Scott sixty percent negligent, plaintiff Dube forty per

*814

cent negligent, and no negligence of Láñe-los and Lewis. Upon such findings Clemtex and Scott, being jointly and severally liable, were ordered to compensate Dube for the sum of $121,395.92, which represents sixty percent of the damages found by the jury. From this judgment Clemtex and Scott bring this appeal on the single proposition that plaintiff, having been compensated by Landos and Lewis for his damages, in an amount in excess of that found by the jury, would thus be receiving greater damages than the jury found he sustained, or a “double recovery.” Appellants cite us

Bradshaw v. Baylor University,

126 Tex. 99, 84 S.W.2d 703 (Comm’n App.1935, opinion adopted).

Since this decision our legislature has enacted

Tex.Rev.Civ.Stat.Ann. art. 2212a

(Vernon Supp.1978) (effective September 1, 1973).

Section 2(e)

of that statute provides:

“If an alleged joint tort-feasor makes a settlement with a claimant but nevertheless is joined as a party defendant at the time of the submission of the case to the jury (so that the existence and amount of his negligence are submitted to the jury) and his percentage of negligence is found by the jury, the settlement is a complete release of the portion of the judgment attributable to the percentage of negligence found on the part of that joint tort-feasor.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.