District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania March 15, 1979, Civ. A. 78-1075 (Skrbina v. Pennsylvania Department of Highways)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1979
OPINION
SNYDER, District Judge.
On May 22, 1977, Paul Skrbina, a resident of Ohio, was seriously injured while driving his motorcycle on a road in Mercer County, Pennsylvania, when he swerved to avoid a “pothole”
1
, struck another “pothole” and was thrown to the ground. He alleges that the Pennsylvania Department of Highways (PennDOT) was negligent in failing to maintain the roadway and/or in failing to warn motorists of the danger. He also alleges that Pavement Specialists, Inc., a Missouri corporation, engaged then in repairing the road under a contract with PennDOT, failed to warn of the danger. PennDOT has moved to dismiss on the grounds that an action against the Commonwealth in federal court is barred by the Eleventh Amendment to the United States Constitution, since recovery could only be paid out of public funds. The Motion will be granted.
I.
In
Mayle v. Pennsylvania Department of Highways,
479 Pa. 384, 388 A.2d 709 (1978), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court abolished sovereign immunity as a defense.
2
Immediately, the question arose whether this abrogation constituted a waiver of the immunity normally afforded the state by the Eleventh Amendment in a federal forum. Judge Donald E. Ziegler of this Court held that it did in
Greenfield v. Vesella,
457 F.Supp. 316 (W.D.Pa.1978).
3
Several other courts have held to the contrary.
See Hernandez v. Whitesell,
462 F.Supp. 569 (E.D. Pa.1978);
Battle
v.
Commonwealth,
No. 78-132 (E.D.Pa., September 19, 1978). The reasoning of these latter cases was that although
Mayle
abolished the common law defense of sovereign immunity in tort cases in Pennsylvania, it did not abrogate sovereign immunity where provided by statute. Thus, where Pennsylvania provided by statute for exclusive jurisdiction in the Commonwealth of all civil actions or proceedings against the Commonwealth, or any officer thereof acting in his official capacity, 17 P.S. § 211.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit