Michigan Court of Appeals June 19, 1979, Docket 78-84 (McFadden v. Downriver Area Narcotics Organization)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-06-1979
J. E. Townsend, J.
This cause arises out of a jeopardy tax assessment and seizure of moneys. Plaintiffs McFadden and McDaniel appeal from an order of the Wayne County Circuit Court issued December 21, 1977, which dismissed plaintiffs’ complaint. Plaintiffs’ complaint sought the return of $5,800, initially confiscated from plaintiff McDaniel following his arrest by the Downriver Area Narcotics Organization, and later seized by defendant Michigan Department of Treasury pursuant to a jeopardy tax assessment and levy against plaintiff McDaniel. Plaintiff McFadden, an attorney at law, claimed ownership of such money by
*750
transfer from plaintiff McDaniel as a "retainer fee” in the criminal case against plaintiff McDaniel.
At the show cause hearing on September 2, 1977, the circuit judge precluded oral argument and denied plaintiff attorney’s request for an evidentiary hearing.
The circuit judge issued an opinion on October 26, 1977, which cited
Craig v Detroit Police Dep't,
397 Mich 185; 243 NW2d 236 (1976), and acknowledged that the taxpayer was entitled to a post-seizure hearing before the circuit court. The opinion recognized that plaintiffs had the burden of proof, and stated that "plaintiff offered no proofs” and found that plaintiff "has not met his burden of pleading and proving” his claims.
On December 21, 1977, the circuit judge entered an order dismissing plaintiffs’ complaint and petition for order to show cause, which recited that the court "found that the plaintiffs have failed to meet their burden of proof’.
It is apparent that the circuit court interpreted
Craig, supra,
as not mandating an evidentiary hearing. We disagree.
The decision in
Craig
mandates a "prompt post-seizure hearing into the
factual basis
for the assessment”. (Emphasis supplied.)
Id.
at 190.
The Supreme Court, by placing the burden of proof on the taxpayer in the post-seizure hearing
(Id.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit