Michigan Supreme Court July 3, 1979, Docket Nos. 59756, 60478. (Calendar Nos. 11, 12) (State Ex Rel. Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney v. Levenburg)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1979

combined-opinion

406 Mich. 455 (1979) 280 N.W.2d 810 STATE ex rel WAYNE COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY v. LEVENBURG STATE ex rel WAYNE COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY v. RICHMOND Docket Nos. 59756, 60478. (Calendar Nos. 11, 12). Supreme Court of Michigan. Argued October 5, 1978. Decided July 3, 1979. William L. Cahalan, Prosecuting Attorney, Edward Reilly Wilson, Principal Attorney, Appeals, and Maura D. Corrigan, Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, for plaintiff. Hyman, Gurwin, Nachman, Friedman & Winkelman (by Abba I. Friedman) and Grant, Schon, *462 Wise & Grant for defendants Levenburg and Anderson's Gardens, Inc. Allen & Tendler and Norman L. Zemke for defendants Richmond. RYAN, J. (to reverse). We granted leave in these consolidated cases to decide whether proof that numerous instances of accosting and soliciting for purposes of prostitution occurred at certain places is sufficient to sustain a finding that such places constitute a public nuisance subject to abatement under MCL 600.3801; MSA 27A.3801 (hereafter, abatement act). We hold that it is and reverse the Court of Appeals.[1] The pertinent facts of these proceedings can be found in Justice KAVANAGH'S opinion. We write separately because we do not agree with his analysis of the law applicable to these cases. Justice KAVANAGH finds that this Court's recent decision, State ex rel Wayne County Prosecutor v Diversified Theatrical Corp, 396 Mich 244; 240 NW2d 460 (1976), strictly limits the application of the abatement act to houses of prostitution, assignation or lewdness where sexual acts are committed. We do not agree, and read that decision as standing solely for the proposition that motion picture theaters may not be enjoined from showing obscene films under the abatement act. *463 MCL 600.3801; MSA 27A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.