Supreme Court of Rhode Island July 3, 1979, 76-191-C.A (State v. Vaccaro)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-07-1979
*789
Bevilacqua, C.J.
In this criminal appeal we are asked to determine whether state and federal constitutional prohibitions against cruel and unusual punishment are violated by the imposition of a mandatory life sentence. We are also requested to decide whether the “right of allocution” contained in art. I., §10, of our state constitution grants to the Superior Court the power to mitigate a punishment previously established by the Legislature.
The record reveals that defendant was tried and convicted in Superior Court of first-degree murder and sentenced to a mandatory term of life imprisonment.
1
Under the terms of G.L. 1956 (1969 Reenactment) §12-19-11, this sentence shall not be suspended and defendant shall not be placed on probation.
2
*790
Prior to sentencing, the following colloquy took place between the court and defendant:
“The Court: Do you care to be heard before I pronounce sentence?
“The Defendant: If you’re going to pronounce sentence, I know first degree murder is life.
“The Court: You know I have no choice.
“The Defendant: Yes. You have a job to do. Nothing else I can say would change the statute that there is. You may go ahead and pronounce sentence.”
The defendant contends that this exchange rings hollow in the face of the right of allocution. He asserts that §12-19-11 by imposing a mandatory sentence without suspension or probation, infringes on judicial discretion in the sentencing process and thus violates the right of allocution contained in art. I, §10. Under defendant’s analysis, proper preservation of this right necessarily implies in the judiciary the power to indefinitely suspend execution of a sentence.
An extensive discussion of the history and development of the right of allocution both at common law and as embodied in the Rhode Island Constitution is provided in the following passages from
Robalewski
v.
Superior Court,
97 R.I. 357, 359-60, 197 A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit