Indiana Court of Appeals June 28, 1979, 3-978A237 (Xaver v. Blazak)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-06-1979

STATON, Judge.

Jacqueline Xaver and her husband, Gerald Xaver, brought this action for money damages against William and Marlene Bla-zak. The Xavers alleged that, as a result of the Blazaks’ negligence, Jacqueline Xaver fell and injured her ankle on the Blazaks’ property. A jury trial commenced. At the close of the Xavers’ case-in-chief, the trial court granted the Blazaks’ motion for judgment on the evidence. The Xavers appeal.

We find no error and we affirm.

The facts relevant to the appeal are as follows: On the evening of September 18, 1975, a group of fellow employees had cocktails and dinner together. Jacqueline Xaver had two martinis before dinner, a glass of wine, and an after-dinner drink. Marlene Blazak invited the group, including Mrs. Xaver, to her home after dinner for a party. She gave directions to her home to everyone; she made no mention of a drainage ditch in her front yard.

Mrs. Xaver, who had never been to the Blazak home before, rode with her boss. After stopping at a liquor store to pick up some beer and liquor for the party, they proceeded to the Blazak residence and pulled into the driveway. They parked at the end of the right-hand side of the double-width driveway, where four cars were already parked, two abreast. The area was illuminated by lights on either side of the garage, as well as a post light in the front yard.

Mrs. Xaver opened the car door, got out of the car, and reached inside to get some beer off the front seat. While facing the car, she stepped backwards to close the car door. She apparently stepped into a drainage ditch which was located approximately 19 inches from the edge of the cement driveway. As a result of the fall, Mrs. Xaver fractured her leg above the ankle joint and suffers recurring problems with her leg.

*655

The drainage ditch or “swale system,” which ran under the Blazaks’ driveway, was constructed by the county in 1973.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.