California Court of Appeal July 11, 1979, Civ. 17415 (Darr v. Lone Star Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1979

combined-opinion

94 Cal.App.3d 895 (1979) 157 Cal. Rptr. 90 JAMES MONROE DARR, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. LONE STAR INDUSTRIES, INC., Defendant and Respondent. Docket No. 17415. Court of Appeals of California, Third District. July 11, 1979. *897 COUNSEL Jones, Lamb, Jarboe & Boli, Michael S. Jarboe, Marvin C. Marx and Lawrence J. Hannan, Jr., for Plaintiff and Appellant. Hardy, Erich & Brown, Van Longyear and John Quincy Brown, Jr., for Defendant and Respondent. OPINION REYNOSO, J. This appeal follows a judgment dismissing plaintiff's personal injury action entered upon an order granting defendant's motion for nonsuit. Plaintiff sustained injury when he dove into the American River from a low level bridge located a short distance downstream from the public bridge crossing at Sunrise Boulevard in Sacramento County. As a result of the dive, plaintiff suffers partial permanent paralysis. Following the accident, plaintiff filed a complaint for damages.[1] At the close of plaintiff's case, defendant filed a motion for nonsuit based on Civil Code section 846, which effectively relieves an "owner of any estate in real *898 property" of liability for injuries resulting from certain recreational activities, including water sports.[2] The trial court granted the motion. (1a) We have determined that, as a matter of law, defendant's interest in the bridge from which plaintiff dove and was injured did not amount to an "ownership of any estate in real property" within the meaning of Civil Code section 846. Consequently, defendant cannot invoke the protection of the statute. We reverse the order granting a nonsuit and remand the matter for further proceedings. I The following recitation of facts serves as useful background. At the time of the accident, defendant was aware that steel culverts and pilings, placed in the river by its predecessor in interest, Pacific Cement Aggregate, Inc. (hereinafter PCA), resided beneath the surface of water below the bridge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.