Appellate Court of Illinois July 19, 1979, 78-489 (Votava v. Material Service Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-07-1979
Mr. JUSTICE RECHENMACHER
delivered the opinion of the court:
This appeal arises out of a personal injury suit wherein the complaint filed is in three counts. Count I is for a maritime tort committed in navigable waters of the United States (viz., negligent maintenance and operation of a submerged barge). Count II is for willful and wanton negligence in connection with the operation and maintenance of said barge and count III was added by amendment on the eve of trial and is based on simple negligence.
The plaintiff is the owner of a 17-foot motor boat. On July 14,1974 (a Sunday), he and three companions were operating this boat on the Illinois River, water skiing and swimming in the vicinity of the defendant’s sand and gravel operation. Defendant operated a “wet” sand and gravel pit about 3,500 feet from the Illinois River which is reached from the Illinois River by means of a channel 100 to 300 feet wide. The pit had originally been a dry one but was converted to a “wet” pit after the channel was dredged out and the water entered, forming a body of water described as a “lake” which was several square miles in area.
A pontoon bridge had been erected by the defendant to block the quarry or pit area from the channel and prominent “No Trespassing” signs were at several points in the channel, as well as at the entrance to the quarry area, warning that this was private property and trespassers would be prosecuted. The pontoon bridge was not in place blocking the channel at all times but was maintained there on weekends, at least during daylight hours, to prevent water skiers and private pleasure boat operators from entering and using the quarry lake as a recreation area. After nightfall, when it was supposed that pleasure boats and skiers were no longer operating in the vicinity, the pontoon bridge was withdrawn so that the barges of the defendant and other barge operators could use the channel, either for delivery or for laying up during the night.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit