Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court May 18, 1979 (First Natl. Bk. of Mount Dora v. Shawmut Bk. of Boston)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-05-1979

Wilkins, J.

In 1970 Harriett Peters, a resident of Connecticut, created a revocable trust in Massachusetts, of which the defendants are now the trustees. Under Article Third of the trust instrument, Peters directed that the trustees pay all estate and inheritance taxes imposed by reason of her death and all her debts and the expenses of administering her estate.

2

On August 6, 1974, while still a resident of Connecticut, Peters executed a will which may be read to direct her executor to pay all estate and inheritance taxes from the residue of her estate.

3

Peters

*139

died on May 19,1975, a resident of Florida, where her will has been admitted to probate, and the plaintiff, a Florida bank, has been appointed executor of her will.

The Florida executor commenced this action in the Probate Court for Suffolk County seeking a judgment that the trustees of the Massachusetts trust must carry out the direction of the trust instrument and pay all Peters’ estate and inheritance taxes and all her debts and the expenses of administering her estate. The defendant trustees deny any obligation to pay estate and inheritance taxes and point to the provisions of article one of Peters’ will, which they argue are controlling and place the entire burden of estate and inheritance taxes on the residue of Peters’ estate. At trial the defendants acknowledged an obligation under the trust to pay Peters’ debts and the expenses of administering her estate.

The trial judge ruled that where there was a conflict between "clear” terms of the will and "prior executed trusts,” the will was the final expression of the decedent’s intent and "the estate must bear the burden of the tax unless the will indicates a contrary intent” where there is no statute in aid of the executor’s contention.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.