Wisconsin Supreme Court January 9, 1979, 76-220 (Hoffman v. Ralston Purina Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1979

HEFFERNAN, J.

The sole issue in this case is whether, where there is a dispute as to liability in tort between two parties and the alleged tortfeasor makes an offer of settlement accompanied by a check and credit memorandum, the retention of the check uncashed and the acquiescence in the fruits of the credit memorandum for a period of more than seven months constitutes an acceptance of that offer. We conclude that under these circumstances, where David Hoffman retained the check and credit memorandum for an unreasonable length of time with the knowledge that both instruments were offered in full settlement of the disputed claim, such re

*449

tention in itself constituted an acceptance of the settlement offer.

In addition, the offeree, Hoffman, in this case had a duty to speak to reject the offer, because the parties Hoffman and Ralston Purina, were engaged in settlement negotiations at the time the offer was made.

The facts revealed at trial show that Hoffman operated a ranch for the raising of Arabian horses. He purchased Purina horse feed through a dealer, Waldschmidt & Sons, Inc. In January of 1973, Waldschmidt delivered a load of Purina feed to Hoffman which allegedly resulted in the illness and death of a number of Hoffman’s horses. It was determined that the feed was contaminated with highway-grade rock salt. In February of 1975, Hoffman commenced an action against the Ralston Purina Company, Waldschmidt & Sons, Inc., and Heritage Mutual Insurance Company.

The action for the injury to his horses was based upon theories of strict liability in tort, negligence, and breach of warranty. Ralston Purina answered, specifically denying the allegations in respect to the facts underlying each theory of recovery set forth in the plaintiff’s complaint and, in addition, alleging the affirmative defense that, prior to the commencement of the lawsuit, the claim had been settled and that there had been a full satisfaction and discharge of the plaintiff’s claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.