Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 13, 1979 (National Ass'n of Government Employees, Inc. v. Central Broadcasting Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-1979

Kaplan, J.

National Association of Government Employees, Inc., is a labor union in the form of a nonprofit Delaware corporation, having a division known as the International Brotherhood of Police Officers with a Local No. 398 in the small town of Ware.

1

The union complained in Superior Court of an alleged libel — a charge of “communism” — made by or on behalf of the defendant Central Broadcasting Corporation, owner of radio station WARE, in the course of a talk show on February 17, 1977, conducted by Jacquelyne Murphy, an employee of the station. After the pleadings were completed by answer to an amended complaint, the defendant moved for summary judgment under Mass. R. Civ. P. 56, 365 Mass. 824 (1974), tendering the pleadings, the plaintiff’s responses to the defendant’s request for admissions, and affidavits of Murphy and Richard H. Vaughan, executive vice president of the defendant. On its part the plaintiff filed an affidavit of William G. Norton, then executive director of the International Brotherhood. A jiidge of the District Court serving by designation in the Superior Court denied the motion without opinion. The defendant applied to a single justice of the Appeals Court under G. L. c. 231, § 118, first paragraph, for relief from the order of denial, and the single justice granted relief by

*222

way of authorizing the defendant to pursue an appeal from the order in the Appeals Court. See

Foreign Auto Import, Inc.

v.

Renault Northeast, Inc.,

367 Mass. 464, 470 (1975).

2

When the appeal was lodged in the Appeals Court, this court took it for direct review. We reverse. Judgment will enter for the defendant.

From the papers supporting and opposing the defendant’s motion, the following appears without material dispute. For some time prior to January 25,1977, the plaintiff on behalf of the town policemen was engaged in collective bargaining with the Ware board of selectmen consisting of three members.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.