New York Court of Appeals July 10, 1979 (G. B. Kent & Sons, Ltd. v. Helena Rubinstein, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-1979

OPINION OF THE COURT

Jones, J.

The erroneous date rule — that a termination notice which erroneously identifies the termination date is nonetheless sufficient to effect a termination as of the first proper termination date — is applicable notwithstanding that termination triggered certain option rights in the recipient of the notice, at least where there is no proof that the application of the rule would impose any substantial forfeiture or prejudice.

In their 1965 agreement Kent granted Rubinstein a worldwide license to manufacture and sell men’s toiletries under the names and marks "Kent” and "Kent of London”. Royalty provisions called for payment of minimum semiannual installments at the end of June and December in each year until the agreement was terminated. Rubinstein was given the right to terminate the agreement as of December 31, 1971 or at the end of any succeeding calendar year by giving Kent one year’s notice in writing. In the event of such termination the agreement provided that Kent would abstain from all usage of the licensed marks for a period of two years following the date of termination. The agreement went on, however, to give Kent an alternative option to elect to use the marks after termination of the agreement on payment to Rubinstein of a grant-1

*564

back royalty for a period of five years. This option was to be exercised by Kent, if at all, in writing not later than 60 days after receipt of notice of termination from Rubinstein.

Their arrangement did not prove to be the commercial success for which the parties had hoped. Meetings were held but attempts to work out new arrangements were fruitless. Rubinstein accordingly ceased manufacture of Kent products in late 1968 and closed out its inventory in 1969. Rubinstein continued to pay the specified minimum royalties on schedule through the semiannual installment due on December 31, 1971.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.